A Sermon on Matthew 13:1-9, 18-23 for Pentecost 7 delivered at St Mary’s, Phoenix
Image: Jean Francois Millet – The Gleaners
Think for a moment about the last time you planted something. Maybe it was tomatoes in a backyard bed, or a single pot of basil on a windowsill. You put the seed in the dirt, you water it, and then — you wait. You don’t control what happens next. That’s the strange, humbling truth about planting. It asks for faith before it gives you evidence.
The Gospel this morning asks us to sit inside that same strange, humbling truth. Matthew reaches for the language of sowing and reaping — because for most of human history, planting and harvest were the shape of life itself. When the Bible wants to talk about God, it reaches for the field, the sowing of seed, the reaping of crops.
Sunday by Sunday, through the readings of the Lectionary, God invites us into a conversation. The point about the seeming randomness of the lectionary selections is that they invite us into the conversation God wants us to have, rather than the safe conversation we prefer to repeat among ourselves.
This was from its first telling, a difficult parable, and appears to be the only one in which Jesus follows up with a private explanation to his dense disciples. It’s now accepted that the private explanation is a later allegorical addition to the oral tradition, which Mark, Matthew, and Luke record. Nevertheless, this is a story about soil and fertility; it’s about seed and fruitfulness.
Yet each time we hear this familiar story, we need to pay attention to how the familiar is made new by the continually changing contexts in which we hear it. Context shapes our reception. Changing context means we hear different elements in the story that we have not noticed before.
What might be the conversation God invites us into this morning through this well-known parable? We receive this parable – in this specific moment of time – a time when we are increasingly hearing the warning about sustainability. Alongside traditional themes of fertility and fruitfulness, we hear a new urgency as we face the challenges of sustainability – practices that will either destroy or ensure a prosperous future for generations to come; actions now that will ensure a future better than the present. In a drought-stricken Southwest, let those who have ears to hear, listen!
But the most shocking thing is that we are confronted by an image of generous recklessness.
A farmer goes out to sow, and he sows – according to the best agricultural practices – recklessly. Seed lands everywhere -on the path; on rocky ground; amidst thorns. Only some of it lands on good soil.
Any farmer witnessing such sowing would wince. That’s wasted seed. That’s poor planning. And yet God — the sower in this parable — doesn’t seem to mind the inefficiency.
God scatters seed everywhere, heedless of the odds, trusting that some seed will germinate in the field, but also along the margins and among the hedgerows.
That should unsettle us a little. We live in a world obsessed with efficiency, with optimized returns, with not wasting a single input. And here is God, sowing wildly, generously, without a business plan.
This reminds me of a small aside. Traditional farming, before modern industrialization took over, allowed for both harvesting and gleaning. The farmer harvested his fields, but his generosity in scattering also provided for the landless – the have-nots – to glean on the margins of his field and beneath the hedgerows. We’ve now removed the hedgerows and eradicated the margins. Today, the farmer takes all – an uncomfortable image of a society that enriches a few while neglecting the many.
This image of God’s recklessness is nonetheless worrisome. And so up and down the land, moralistic preachers will try to ignore it by reducing things to the level of the individual with exhortations to the faithful to piously reflect on their own fertility or barrenness. With faces full of accusation, they will ask their listeners: do you believe enough? Is your lifestyle pure enough? Are your relationships holy enough? Holiness – meaning passing the Church’s excusive smell test.
Yet, each of us has places in the heart where the word is snatched away; places where it springs up without root only to fade with the next enthusiasm to capture us; places where it is choked by our fears, as well as places where it bears fruit.
This morning I want to ask a more gentle yet searching question.
What does a fruitful life — a sustainable life —look like?
I’d suggest three things.
First, receptivity — a lifelong willingness to keep tilling the soil of our own hearts to receive the Word as seed that takes root – a lifetime’s work.
Second, engagement that bears fruit is a step beyond receiving. Engagement takes us beyond ourselves, recognizing that we can bear fruit only when we support societal structures that promote equality and justice. None of us can truly flourish unless all are offered equal opportunities to flourish
Third, action because understanding that never moves your hands and feet isn’t yet fruitful. It’s still just a seed awaiting germination. Germination results from realizing our gratitude to a God who risks all for us. And living accordingly – lives shaped by gratitude – expressed through generous living.
Receiving, engaging, and acting. That’s the shape of a fruitful life. And notice — none of these is optional. A life of fruitfulness needs all three, the way a harvest needs seed, soil, and rain.
Our fruitfulness must reach beyond our own contentment and toward the flourishing of the wider world God has risked all for. That’s uncomfortable, because it means asking hard questions — about how our society farms, how it treats workers, how it distributes what’s grown, who gets bread and who doesn’t. A sustainable society, like a sustainable field, is one where justice falls like dew from heaven — creating the conditions where people and communities, not just crops, can flourish. In a season like ours, with so much anxiety and so much division, that kind of agitation for the common good isn’t optional. It’s necessary to risk making good trouble.
Scattering seed only for birds to eat. We might expect God to be more careful with something so precious. But maybe the seed lost to the birds isn’t wasted after all. Maybe it becomes food that carries life somewhere else entirely — into fields the sower never intended to plant, in ways no one could have predicted or planned.
That is the God we follow: a God of risky grace, who scatters generously rather than efficiently, and who trusts the harvest to forces far beyond our control.
If that’s who God is, then perhaps that’s also who we’re called to be — people willing to scatter the seed of love expressed as social justice without demanding a guaranteed return. Willing to risk being generous in a culture that prizes caution. Willing to plant seed for a harvest we may never live to see.
That kind of risk isn’t reckless. It’s faithful. And the ground we’re being asked to sow — inhospitable as it may look right now — may be far richer than we imagine.
May we continue to work at fertilizing our own soil, to with risky abandon scatter the seed of the Word generously in order to reap a harvest of peace – but not any kind of peace, but peace with justice.
Amen.